Alex
Umsted
Byrd
EDRD
651/Reading Reflection
15
July 2014
Teaching Literacy in
the Digital Age:
Inspiration for All Levels and Literacies
|
Page #
(Kindle) |
Quote
|
Reflection
|
|
Loc
552
|
“Not
only do we ding that showing students digital book trailers is a great way to
spark interest in reading specific titles, we take this approach an important
step further: we assign students to create their own book trailers. They understand that an important dimension
to this assignment is that the book trailers they create will be used to
inform and motivate other students to read those same books.”
|
Though
I have never heard of book trailers before, I absolutely love the idea. Like a commercial for a film, the book
trailer serves as the advertisement for the book. For students who may not like reading or
have a harder time visualizing texts, book trailers can be just what they
need to actually pick up that book and read.
Additionally, I love the students are the ones making the book
trailers. Not only will this show that
they comprehend the text, the creation of the book trailer can serve as
another form of assessment.
|
|
Loc
705
|
(Online
animation) “Lori then taught students the basics of selling the short stories
they had written using animation. She
shared the importance of considering audience and purpose before selecting
text, images, and sound. She also
stressed the need to match content and style to an audience, along with the
need to hook the audience by carefully considering characters, conflicts, and
plot points that should be highlighted.”
|
By
adding in the online animation aspects to the 3-5 page story Lori asked her
students to write, the students are being introduced to so much more than
they were originally aware of. Though
the creative story is the backbone to this project, the animation aspect
shows students how to consider important aspects like audience, sounds,
direction, and style. There are so
many more elements that these students are being introduced to because they
are essentially recreating their stories.
Again, this project would also be very helpful for students who have a
hard time visualizing texts. Through
this project, students are also critically thinking about the text they have
created.
|
|
Loc
852
|
“…I
provide each student with a short story and a blank storyboard with exactly
20 empty shots. I tell the students
that they are to assume the role of the director and using the assigned short
story, sketch out, in exactly 20 shots, a filmic version of their story. By limiting the shots to 20, everyone has
the same framework from which to work.”
|
The
storyboarding part of The 20-Shot Short
Story seems to be one of the most imperative steps. By giving each student an assigned text and
telling them that they only have 20 shots to tell the whole story, students
are forced to closely pay attention to details and see what information is
the most critical. Students are
learning how to summarize and identify the important information in
texts. Additionally, they are also
being given the opportunity to make the story as explicitly visual as
possible, which will help better their understanding of what is happening in
the major plot.
|
|
Loc
967
|
“…Regardless
of whether I assign this [movie production] as a group or an individual
project, I always have students do most of the planning and writing
individually. Then I assign them to
groups and have them decide on which script they’ll produce.”
|
I
like the way Katz still emphasizes the importance of the individual writing
process. Though some films are done
individually and some are done in groups, each student still has to produce
just as much writing as the next. This
is very important because, ultimately, this is one of the most important
goals in the English classroom. Also,
I like that the groups are able to decide which script they like the most
because it gives students a goal to work towards as they are engaging in
their writing process.
|
|
Loc
1100
|
Do-It-Yourslef
Digital 3D Storytelling in general
|
Though
this project was originally created for 3rd graders, I think that
it can easily be turned into a high school English project. Though high school students will obviously
have a better base knowledge of words, students can still use the idea of
finding or identifying words by using their critical thinking skills when
reading and/or writing a short story to decipher what is the most important
in the text. Additionally, the project
will teach them how to organize their thoughts/information and explicitly
visualize what they are reading.
|
|
Loc
1592
|
(Graphic
Novels) “The high level of engagement created by the visual art aspect of the
project provides momentum that in turn engages students in the writing
dimension of the project. While
extended text passages are not unheard of in graphic novels, communication
that must be accomplished in the text is generally done with only a few
sentences at a time.”
|
Creating
graphic novels is a great outlet for teaching students how to carefully
choose how they want articulate their message when writing. When students are only given a small amount
of space, they cannot write absolutely everything they want; it is necessary
to formulate what information is needed to be said and not said. For example, some information can be
explained through visuals instead of words in graphic novels. This genre is a great way to teach students
how to be consciously aware of different expectations in various writing
styles.
|
|
Loc
2131
|
(Creating
Podcast/Radio show) “Students spent the first two days in the computer lab
doing research and gathering support material to answer questions and learn
more about their topics. Students
gathered relevant information from multiple digital sources and integrated it
into their podcasts.”
|
Because
informational texts are being pushed even more into our everyday curriculum,
this project is a great way to make informative texts still seem
engaging. Even though they are
eventually going to be turning their research into a radio show, they are
learning many needed skills. Some include: proper research techniques,
summarizing, finding important information, comprehension, debate, and
forming a strong argument.
|
|
Loc
2290
|
“As
students started their first notebook, Mrs. Smith asked them to capture some
of their initial thinking by creating their first note. Very much in the spirit of a freewrite, she
wants them to use this first note as a way to document the research
experience over the next few weeks, adding to it as they see fit.”
|
Even
the research itself is obviously very vital, a notebook discussing the
experience Samantha had as she conducted research is also very important
because she can refer back to it when she does research in the future. I love the idea of keeping record of the
experience because one can learn about their growth as a researcher
throughout the project. Additionally,
students may refer back to this if they ever get stuck with their research;
they can see what other areas they had broadly looked at before and revisit
the concepts again if necessary.
|
|
Loc
3049
|
(Making
a Mini News Station) “Beyond its authentication of the Common Core English
Language Arts literacy goals, the DNN program validates and concretizes
college and career readiness. Indeed,
students walk away from this program not only able to demonstrate competence
in using technology but also to use persuasive, argumentative, and
information language as required in the Common Core ELA Standards.”
|
Having
middle school students produce their own News is one of the most ambitious
project we have read about thus far in the book. This is definitely applicable to the high
school classroom, and it could possibly be taught alongside a government
and/or social studies class. By having
students produce their own News program twice a week, students gain so much
knowledge and experience. They are not
only learning about current events, but they are also practicing writing,
vocational skills, organization, argumentative tactics, and technological
skills. Along with meeting many of the
English common core standards, students are learning about serious career
opportunities. This project uses common
core standards in such a way that students are learning what they are supposed
to be while they are also gaining real life experience.
|
|
Loc
3165
|
(Video
Feedback)
“Video
messages are another way to provide video feedback. Using webcam, teachers can respond to
student work in a holistic way, addressing their entire piece. I have found most success using this in
conjunction with the scoring guide you used for that assignment. By recording your comments talking through
the scoring rubric with students, your video gives you the opportunity to
“speak” with each student.”
|
I
especially like this feedback tactic because it is a personal way for the
teacher to talk to students without taking up too much time in the
classroom. Additionally, students will
see the sincerity of the teacher’s comments and see how much time and effort
they put into reading/viewing the students work. Additionally, students will be able to look
back on the videos as they create more work in the future. This, obviously, cannot be done if the
teacher gives individual conferences to each student in person. Students also do not feel as exposed by
getting feedback this way. Though they
know and see what the teacher thought of their work, students do not feel the
added pressure of receiving criticism directly from the teacher in
person. Many students get very stressed
over such conferences.
|
I agree that the storyboard part of the project is an absolutely necessary part. I really liked how she showed the different stages of taking out unnecessary words in the storyboard and replacing them with illustrated details. This will help students to show, not tell and will help them understand the most important details of their projects.
ReplyDeleteI was totally overwhelmed with the news project chapter. Some of these ideas seem great, but also impossible to manage! I'm sure that one day I'll feel comfortable to assign a project as intricate as this one, but envisioning this in my own classroom during my first year of teaching seems absolutely daunting. I liked your idea of splitting the project with a government or social studies class so that this project doesn't dominate your class time. How would you fit this into a unit? Would you have this be an isolated project or would you have students do small bits per week? Also, we've been taught to plan our units thematically... how would you fit this into a unit?
ReplyDeleteYour last point about video feedback raises good points, though I'm still not sold on the idea. I think that receiving and giving constructive feedback face-to-face is an important skill for all people to learn. One of my greatest fears of too much technology in our lives is that it might strip humans of primal ways of interacting. I have heard of research and studies on today's generation of children who do not gesticulate (use their hands when they talk) because they are so used to communicating via technology. I wonder if we use technology as a buffer for even more types of communication, such as feedback, that an important art may be lost... I don't know, I guess though sometimes things may be hard, I think they are good for us in the long run. I'm just not sure how much we should let technology stand in for person-to-person interactions, like, where's the line? As teachers, we can model these types of interactions intentionally, which is why I think we, of all people, should be giving direct feedback.
ReplyDelete